TOP Moda Bank-78 Women's Mid Calf Round Toe Stitched Flat Boots - Comfortable & Stylish Ankle Boots for Casual Wear, Office & Fall Fashion

I purchased these boots part way through the winter of 2015. I wore them for church/formal events from fall to spring 2015-2018 and they held up pretty good. They weren't the warmest boot (for MN winter's) and they don't have very good grip on ice, but if you are looking for a fashion boot these would work fine. I think around 2017 the toes and heels started to scuff a bit and the pleather peeled off, at some point one of the buttons fell off (but I was able to glue it back on) and at the end of 2018 the sole started to separate from the boot (see pictures). I just tried wearing them again this fall and my feet got wet so it's time to get new boots. I would consider these again but I see the price has almost doubled from when I bought them originally so I'm going to try something else this time.